Saints vs Killers

Fine, this may not be the most inspired title I've ever written, but the following two jackets sure are. So, I'm going to get a leather jacket as a 'yay, you're a doctor' thing. I narrowed my options to the following two:

All Saints Dresden jacket Kill City Drapey jacket



Where shall I start? Price wise, they're quite close. The Kill City one has a strong Rick Owen feel to it, but the All Saints one has those SHOULDERS and that ZIPPER. Kill City is asymmetry at it's best, but the All Saints one has that cowl collar that's just out of this world. That being said, I dunno what to pick. Your thoughts?
And apparently I'm turning into a fashion drone and might want to forever live at Oak. Damn it.